Banner
Navigation
loco-info.com
The reference for locomotives and railcars
Navigation
Random
Search
Compare
Settings
Tender Locomotives 4-4-4 “Reading” and 4-4-6 “Thuile”
UIC Classification 2'B2' and 2'B3'
go back
The two classes of “Jubilees” of the Canadian Pacific were the only successful classes of 4-4-4 locomotives
The two classes of “Jubilees” of the Canadian Pacific were the only successful classes of 4-4-4 locomotives
collection Ronald Amberger

The wheel arrangement 4-4-4 designates a steam locomotive that has a two-axle leading bogie, two coupled axles and a two-axle trailing bogie. With the unique wheel arrangement 4-4-6, the trailing bogie has three axles. In different countries, this wheel arrangement is referred to as follows:

Reading / Thuile

UIC: 2'B2' / 2'B3'

Whyte: 4-4-4 / 4-4-6

Switzerland: 2/6 / 2/7

France: 222 / 223

Turkey: 26 / 27

The 4-4-4 locomotive can be described as an Atlantic with a two-axle trailing truck to allow for a larger firebox. While tank versions could be found in different countries, the tender variant was very rare. These were either build for speed records or for hauling light trains at high speed due to their smaller adhesive weight compared to six-coupled express locomotives.

The first 4-4-4 tender locomotives came from Europe. In Germany, the Prussian State Railways built two prototypes in 1904 which were streamlined cab forwards which attained a speed of 137 km/h or 85 mph. In 1907, the Bavarian S 2/6 set a record with 154 km/h or 96 mph. But despite this, the Prussians completely abandoned this concept and the Bavarians ordered the S 3/6 Pacifics instead. In France, the Nord tested a single 4-4-4 in 1909 which had been rebuilt from an Atlantic and was again rebuilt to a Ten-wheeler after the trials.

In North America, the Philadelphia & Reading was the first to build the 4-4-4 type. These were the four locomotives of the class C-1a and so this wheel arrangement was called “Reading” in the USA. The Baltimore & Ohio was the only other US railroad to build a 4-4-4 tender locomotive in 1934 that was called class J-1 “Lady Baltimore”. Both these classes failed to become a success. In Canada, the 4-4-4 became a greater success with the Canadian Pacific operating a total of 25 semi-streamlined members of the classes F-1a and F-2a.

A similar, but really exotic wheel arrangement was 4-4-6. French engineer Henri Thuile proposed express locomotives with drivers of three meters (9 ft 10 in) and a very huge firebox. He chose 6-4-8 or 6-4-6 as possible wheel arrangements, but the manufacturer Schneider decided to built a 4-4-6 cab-forward variant with drivers of only 2.5 meters (8 ft 2 in) in 1899. This locomotive was tested by the État and demonstrated a speed of 117 km/h (73 mph). The death of Thuile while riding this locomotive ended the program, with no other locomotive of this wheel arrangement ever built.

The Bavarian S 2/6 could set a record of 154 km/h in 1907, but had insufficient starting tractive effort for heavy express trains
The Bavarian S 2/6 could set a record of 154 km/h in 1907, but had insufficient starting tractive effort for heavy express trains
Bavarian S 2/6
Germany | 1906
only one produced
Image of locomotive

The S 2/6 was a one-off that was only intended for testing higher speeds. It was ordered in December 1905 and developed and built within just four months. In terms of wheel arrangement and driving wheel diameter, it corresponds to the Prussian test locomotive S 9, with which high-speed tests had been undertaken shortly before. In contrast to this, however, the S 2/6 was otherwise based on near-series technologies.

In addition to the two coupled wheel sets with 2,200 mm wheels, the measures used in various places to reduce air resistance are distinguishing features of the locomotive. Other express locomotives of the time also had a cone-shaped smokebox door and a driver's cab tapered at the front, but there was a smooth transition from the boiler to the driver's cab. The streamlined cladding of the chimney, steam dome and cylinders went even further.

With a large grate area compared to other locomotives, a very good evaporation performance was obtained. Together with the four-cylinder compound engine, a calculated indicated output of up to 2,200 hp was achieved during test drives. On July 2, 1907, with four wagons with a total weight of 150 tonnes it traveled at a speed of 154.5 km/h. This value was a world record and caused a stir internationally.

Immediately after the test runs, the S 2/6 was put into regular use, where it was able to reach a speed of 120 km/h with trains weighing 360 tonnes. In operation in Bavaria, it was particularly unpopular with the planning staff because it was a one-off and its characteristics differed greatly from the other locomotives used. Compared to the S 3/6, the S 2/6 had more power, but with only two coupled axles it could generate less traction, which made planning the simultaneous use of both locomotives very difficult.

In 1910 the locomotive was relocated to the Palatinate network, which belonged to Bavaria, and was more popular there. On the Reichsbahn it would have become class 15, in which it would have been the only locomotive with a 4-4-4 wheel arrangement. However, after returning to Bavaria, it was decommissioned, refurbished and taken to the Nuremberg Transport Museum in 1925, where it is to this day.

General
Built1906
ManufacturerMaffei
Axle config4-4-4 (Reading) 
Gauge4 ft 8 1/2 in (Standard gauge)
Dimensions and Weights
Length69 ft 3 11/16 in
Length loco45 ft 2 5/16 in
Wheelbase38 ft 4 5/8 in
Rigid wheelbase7 ft 7 5/16 in
Total wheelbase60 ft 8 1/4 in
Empty weight164,906 lbs
Service weight181,881 lbs
Adhesive weight71,650 lbs
Axle load35,825 lbs
Water capacity6,868 us gal
Fuel capacity15,432 lbs (coal)
Boiler
Grate area50.6 sq ft
Firebox area177.6 sq ft
Tube heating area2,142 sq ft
Evaporative heating area2,319.6 sq ft
Superheater area403.6 sq ft
Total heating area2,723.3 sq ft
Power Plant
Driver diameter86.61 in
Boiler pressure218 psi
Expansion typecompound
Cylindersfour, HP: 16 1/8 x 25 3/16 in
and LP: 24 x 25 3/16 in
Power
Power sourcesteam
Indicated power2,172 hp (1,620 kW)
Top speed93 mph
Starting effort19,315 lbf
with start valve23,178 lbf
Calculated Values
Optimal speed72 mph
steam locomotive
express
Von Borries compound
Anton Hammel
last changed: 02/2022
Prussian S 9 Altona 561 and 562
Germany | 1904
2 produced
Altona 561, the streamlined vehicle
Altona 561, the streamlined vehicle
works photo Henschel

In search of a very fast steam locomotive for lighter trains, railway inspector Gustav Wittfeld developed the S 9 with the 4-4-4 wheel arrangement, which should not be confused with the S 9 that was mass-produced a few years later. The tender from the Association of German Engineers called for a machine that should be able to pull a 120-tonne train at at least 120 and if possible 150 km/h. The special thing about the two test locomotives was that they had an additional front driver's cab, which was intended for better observation of the route. The engine driver talked to the second driver via voice connection, who was in the rear cab in the usual position together with the fireman. Since the symmetrical wheel arrangement also allowed high reverse speeds, there was also a driver's cab at the end of the tender.

The first vehicle was provided with casing that was wedge-shaped at the front and from which it was hoped that a power saving of 250 to 300 hp would be achieved. There were a few windows in the side walls on both sides of the boiler so that this room could be used as a connecting passage. The tender also had an aisle and allowed to walk into the train. The second locomotive did not have the casing, but also had a wedge-shaped front on the front cab. The saturated engine was one of the few in Germany with three cylinders and compound steam expansion. The center cylinder took on the live steam and the two outer ones served as low-pressure cylinders. While the high-pressure cylinders of locomotives with two and four cylinders have a significantly smaller diameter, all three had the same dimensions here.

During the tests with the first locomotive, one quickly came to the realization that the expectations could not be met. The locomotive had about 1,400 hp, with which the 109-tonne train with three cars could be accelerated to 128 to 137 km/h on different runs. With a train that was twice as long and weighing 224 tonnes, it took more than ten minutes to reach the 110 km/h mark and the maximum speed was 118 km/h.

Since these achievements were not in proportion to the very complex construction, there was no series production. As a result, not only was the casing of the first engine removed, but the front cabs were also removed and the locomotives used like conventional steam locomotives. In addition, an adjustment of the offset between the cylinders was necessary, since at certain speeds there had been very strong shaking movements. A very similar construction, designed at the same time by Henschel, was a tank locomotive with the designation T 16. It had the wheel arrangement 4-6-4T and was intended for uphill stretches in Thuringia. Since it had an axle load of 20 tonnes, it could not be used on most routes and was returned to the manufacturer after a short time. The two S 9 were only used until 1918 and then scrapped.

General
Built1904
ManufacturerHenschel
Axle config4-4-4 (Reading) 
Gauge4 ft 8 1/2 in (Standard gauge)
Dimensions and Weights
Length81 ft 5 3/16 in
Length loco480 ft 7 11/16 in
Wheelbase40 ft 8 3/16 in
Rigid wheelbase8 ft 4 13/16 in
Empty weight174,165 lbs
Service weight197,313 lbs
Adhesive weight80,689 lbs
Axle load37,479 lbs
Water capacity4,385 us gal
Fuel capacity15,432 lbs (coal)
Boiler
Grate area47.3 sq ft
Firebox area164 sq ft
Tube heating area2,632 sq ft
Evaporative heating area2,796 sq ft
Total heating area2,796 sq ft
Power Plant
Driver diameter86.61 in
Boiler pressure203 psi
Expansion typecompound
Cylindersthree, HP: 20 5/8 x 24 13/16 in
and LP: 20 5/8 x 24 13/16 in
Power
Power sourcesteam
Indicated power1,408 hp (1,050 kW)
Top speed85 mph
Starting effort21,040 lbf
with start valve25,248 lbf
Calculated Values
Optimal speed43 mph
steam locomotive
express
streamline
prototype
cab forward
last changed: 01/2022
Later state after the rebuilding
Later state after the rebuilding
Locomotive Magazine, August 1934
Showing 1 to 2 of 2
Search
loadding loading...

We use cookies to save the following settings:

  • selected navigation structure
  • selected language
  • preferred units
  • spelling of railway company names

If you refuse the use of cookies, the settings will only be retained for the current session and will be reset to the default values the next time you visit the site.

Display of units

Here you can set the desired unit system for the technical data.

  • Metric: Lengths in meters, weights in tonnes, and volumes in cubic meters
  • Imperial (UK): Lengths in feet/inches, weights in long tons and volumes in imperial gallons
  • Imperial (US): Lengths in feet/inches, weights in pounds, and volumes in US gallons
  • Individual: Depends on the country of origin of each locomotive
Operator names

Here you can set the display of railway company names.

  • Short: Abbreviation or short form of the name
  • Standard: commonly used name, partially translated to English
  • Complete: full name in local language